Personal Valuables Insurance

No matter what you treasure – we can help you protect it.


Are dedicated to helping you choose coverage that’s right for you.

Licensed Professionals

You can count on our agents to help you make good decisions about your insurance protection.

Local Presence

Our agents have offices in your neighborhood and are a part of your community.

Claims Assistance

You might be uneasy about starting a claim, but our agents will guide you through the claims process.


Average Annual Savings

Licensed Agents

Years in Business


On average, our customers save over $500 a year by switching to Baehr Insurance

Start With a Free Hassle-Free Quote

Fill out the form below and one of our agents will reach out to you soon to go over our process. Let us see if we can help you save some money!

12 + 14 =


Safe driving discount
If you’re a safe driver with a good driving record, you could get a discount on your auto coverage.
Car safety equipment discount

You can save on your insurance coverage if your car is equipped with safety equipment like factory-installed air bags, passive restraint, anti-theft devices and anti-lock brakes. 

Multi-car discount?
If we insure two or more of your cars, you could qualify for a discount. (All the vehicles in your household must be owned and used by the driver we insure.)
Multi-policy discount?
A discount is available if you have a qualifying life insurance policy or home policy in addition to your ERIE auto insurance.
Reduced usage discount
If you’re not using your car for at least 90 consecutive days during the policy period, you could be eligible for a discount.
Young drivers
Unmarried drivers under 21 who reside with their parents may be eligible for additional savings.
Annual payment plan
You can save by paying your auto premium in one lump sum.